7 Best Cornhole Bags for Your Next Tailgate Party10 min read

A cornhole game is only as good as the people you play it with. That said, good cornhole equipment also makes a huge difference in how well you play and ultimately, whether you enjoy the game. This includes not just the cornhole boards but also the bags you use. The best cornhole bags will have the right feel and the right weight, so there’s more accuracy and comfort when you toss them. You’d be surprised at the difference a good cornhole bag can make in your technique.

Plus, high-quality cornhole bags will obviously be made using high-end material that’s much more durable. So they could last for a while before you need to replace them. This makes all the difference for those of you who play cornhole regularly and like to set it up for the occasional tailgate party. You will need a good set of cornhole bags that will withstand frequent use by multiple players.

So the next time you’re in the market for bean bag toss bags, take some time to do your research, and invest in a set that’s worth the money rather than settle for the bags that came with your cornhole set. To make that research process easier for you, we’ve put together some of the best cornhole bags in the market.

We’ve taken into account various factors like durability, material, color availability, accessories, etc. and rated them for you so you can easily decide which set to buy. But it’s important to note that none of these bags are ACO-certified, although they are ACO-approved.

The ACO (American Cornhole Organization) is very specific with their cornhole bag certifications. The organization only has four certified bag partners for their tournaments – ACO Fasttraxx Bags, Beer Belly Bags, Reynolds Bags, and Ultra Cornhole Bags. And these cost almost twice as much as the bags on our list. So if you’re specifically looking for bags to use at a tournament, you’d want to head on to the ACO website.

For now, our main focus is on the best cornhole bags that you can use for casual play at tailgate parties and friendly matches. Let’s take a look:

#1: SC Cornhole Weather Resistant Cornhole Bags – Our Top Recommendation

Main Highlights: Great feel and weight, suitable for all-weather use

This set of weather resistant cornhole bags from SC Cornhole meets all the regulations set by the ACO – 6”x6” dimensions and 14-16 ounces. So although they’re not specifically ACO certified, they’re the next best thing. And the best part? They’ll only cost you about half the price of ACO-certified bags. Unless you’re looking for tournament bags, these would be our top pick.

What We Like:

These bags are made of durable 12oz duck cloth canvas, giving them excellent feel, weight and durability. And we all know how important those factors are to ensure good gameplay.

These bags are also resistant to weather and critter, because they’re filled with plastic pellets. So even if you feel like a little rain won’t stop you from winning your cornhole game, these bags will have your back.

If you’ve gotten tired of the usual red and blue color combination, there’s another reason why you’ll love this set. You can choose from any of the 35 different color combinations – whether you like subtle black and gray or the more patriotic stars and stripes.

SC Cornhole also provides a 1-year warranty on their bags and will give you replacement bags in case of any damage. That’s another added advantage of this set, making it one of the best cornhole bags sets for casual play.

Main Flaws:

• Doesn’t come with a carry bag/case
• Stitching is susceptible to coming loose; may need reinforcement

Check it out on Amazon

#2: Johnson Enterprises 8 Standard Cornhole Bags

Main Highlights: American-made, great throwing accuracy, custom color options

One of the main concerns when it comes to bean bag toss bags is the filling – corn vs. resin. While most people prefer resin for weather resistance and durability, a lot of loyal cornholers still prefer the traditional corn filling. They say that the dust released as the corn breaks down during play helps the bags slide more easily on the cornhole board.

So if you’re a loyal fan of corn-filled bags, the standard cornhole bags from Johnson Enterprises are an excellent option.

What We Like:

Besides meeting all the ACA (American Cornhole Association) regulations in terms of size, weight, and material, these bags come with double-stitched seams that give added durability. They have a nice weight to them, giving you a balanced and accurate throw. The best part about these bags is that they are 100% made in the USA, which is great for cornholers that like to support American businesses.

Since they’re made with heavyweight (12oz) duck canvas and contain corn kernel filling, they offer excellent play and a comfortable weight to make more accurate throws. If colors are a big concern to you, you’ll have 25 color options to choose from. Plus, you can even get custom colors if you’re looking for something very specific that’s not part of their offering.

Main Flaws:

• Doesn’t come with a carry bag/case
• Not suitable for all-weather use
• 1-year replacement warranty only covers replacement in case of stitching failure

Check it out on Amazon

#3: Play Platoon Weather Resistant Cornhole Bean Bags

Main Highlights: Most affordable set, comes with carry bag

If neither corn nor resin meets your approval, you can always opt for sand-filled bags such as the weather resistant bags from Play Platoon. This is the most affordable set on our list, but the price difference isn’t a lot either. And although the color choices are a bit more limited than the previous sets, you can still choose from 10 solid color combinations and a stars and stripes set.

What We Like:

These bags come with double-stitched seams to prevent them from bursting on impact. So they’d be perfect for that friend with the exceptionally strong throw. The sand filling in these bags can withstand any kind of weather. And although it’s not recommended to wash them, you can stop worrying about accidentally leaving them out in the rain.

Unlike the first two sets on our list, this set comes with a mesh carry bag so you can easily store them or bring them along to tailgate parties. Plus, there’s also the fact that Play Platoon gives you a lifetime replacement warranty for all of their products. This means you’re basically set for a while if you get these bags.

Main Flaws:

• Doesn’t offer the same feel and throw as traditional corn-filled bags
• Some bags have had seams coming loose (which isn’t a total deal-breaker because of the replacement warranty)

Check it out on Amazon

#4: Free Donkey Sports Cornhole Bags

Main Highlights: Great throw and accuracy, custom color options

This is the closest alternative to the second one on our list. Although there aren’t a lot of differences between the two, this option is an excellent fallback in case you want to buy from a different brand. The main difference is that the canvas used here isn’t as heavy as the previous option, so there could be slight variations in the weight and feel of these bags.

What We Like:

The corn kernel filling of these bags give you an authentic playing experience and better throwing accuracy. And the canvas used to make these bags can hold up pretty well, lasting you for several games.

There are a lot more color combination choices for this set – 39! But even if your choice of colors does not exist among the list, you can always go for a custom color combination. Plus, this set costs slightly less than the alternative.

Main Flaws:

• Doesn’t come with a carry bag/case
• Not suitable for all-weather use
• Unclear warranty terms

Check it out on Amazon

#5: Tailgating Pros Regulation Cornhole Bags

Main Highlights: American-made, great throw and accuracy, custom color options

Tailgating Pros is one of the most reputable cornhole manufacturers. Aside from cornhole boards for tailgating, the company also manufactures accessories like cornhole lights. So even when it comes to cornhole bags, they produce some of the best in the market.

Take this set of regulation cornhole bags, for example. With the right combination of heavyweight canvas material and corn kernel filling, they give you a nice weight and feel that ensures more accuracy in your throw.

What We Like:

In addition to meeting all the ACA specifications, these cornhole bags also have double-stitched seams that give you extra durability, making them tough enough to withstand strong impact on any surface. This means that even if you have to play cornhole on gravely surfaces at your tailgate parties or camping trips, these bags won’t burst.

The fact that these cornhole bags were made in the USA is another appealing factor for many cornholers. And for those of you who like color variations, this set lets you choose custom color combinations aside from the 25 existing combinations.

Main Flaws:

• Doesn’t come with a carry bag/case
• Not suitable for all-weather use
• 1-year replacement warranty only covers stitching failure

Check it out on Amazon

#6: Victory Tailgate Corn-Filled Regulation Cornhole Bags

Main Highlights: American-made, excellent feel and weight, comes with a carry bag

So far, only one of the sets we’ve listed has come with a carry bag. This Victory Tailgate set would be the next one. But although these bags are labeled “tournament grade” and fit all the specifications of the ACA, they are not specifically ACO certified. That also means they don’t cost as much as ACO-certified cornhole bags.

What We Like:

These bags are handmade in the USA, which gives a lot of cornholers a good reason to buy from this brand. Even the corn kernel fillings are American-sourced, making the bags as good as the ones used by professionals. And with the 10oz duck cloth fabric, these bags have a nice feel and weight to enhance your game play.

The string bag that comes with this set of cornhole bags gives you an easy storage solution. Now it’s much easier to bring your bags along with you to tailgate parties and camping trips. Plus, there’s also the fact that you can choose from 45 different color combinations.

Main Flaws:

• Not suitable for all-weather use
• Insufficient warranty information

Check it out on Amazon

#7: Cornhole Galaxy Premium Weather Resistant Cornhole Bags

Main Highlights: American-made, great feel and weight, suitable for all-weather use, custom color options

The weather resistant bag set from Cornhole Galaxy is another great option for those who don’t necessarily need corn kernel fillings. This set is also the most premium one on our list and therefore, the most expensive. At the same time, it still doesn’t cost quite as much as the high-end ACO-certified tournament bags.

What We Like:

The heavyweight duck cloth adds a little extra weight to these bags, giving them a nice feel and better throwing accuracy. They tend to last longer as well, so you’ll be getting your money’s worth for this set. With double-stitched seams, these bags hold up pretty well in spite of heavy impact and use.

Since they’re filled with plastic pellets, you can even give them the occasional wash and let them air dry without worrying about molding and mildew. Besides these factors, there’s also the fact that these bags are handmade in the USA. And you can get your favorite color combination customized, if it’s not among the 17 color combinations they already have.

Main Flaws:

• Slightly pricier than other options
• Doesn’t come with a carry bag/case
• Unclear warranty information

Check it out on Amazon

Bottom Line

Although we have a top pick, that doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the best option for you. Your personal preferences and requirements will help you make a choice between these seven best cornhole bags. Your main consideration should be in terms of filling – whether you’d want plastic, corn, or sand. Besides that, you can consider secondary factors like warranty, price, color availability, and accessories.